一题一练

{"status":"success","code":200,"message":"","data":{"id":71,"name":"民商诉综合","bank_id":399,"biz_id":88960,"category_id":3988,"biz_type":"ai","status":"doing","total_score":18,"score":0,"time":0,"total_num":1,"right_num":0,"wrong_num":0,"path":null,"questions":[{"id":88960,"bank_id":399,"type":"material","num":0,"index":0,"year":null,"score":18,"title":"王明于2020年2月10日在东山区开设甲公司,王明作为甲公司的唯一股东并担任甲公司经理，后王明于2021年3月10日与李丽结婚,结婚后李丽作为甲公司财务，2022年3月15日甲公司与西河区乙公司签订设备购买合同,价款200万元,甲公司首付100万元,剩余100万元在2023年支付完,每次支付10万元,于每月月初支付,双方在合同中约定产生纠纷由西河区人民法院管辖。王明承诺,如果甲公司还不了款王明就还款,后甲公司,王明,乙公司在合同上签字,李丽未签字。甲公司支付了2期后,就不再支付剩余款项。乙公司了解到是因为甲公对设备操作不熟导致产量低无法支付设备价款,乙公司又与甲公司签订培训合同,由乙公司派人对甲公司员工进行培训,培训费20万元,之后乙公司反复催告甲公司支付设备价款和培训费,但甲公司并不配合,只在2023年1月,给乙公司转账15万元,注明“履行合同款”,乙公司询问这笔款项是哪一笔价款,甲公司并未回应。乙公司起诉到法院,要求解除合同并支付两个合同项下的价数,后乙公司查明,甲公司无力支付价款,起诉没意义,遂在一审开庭前撤回起诉,法院准许。另查明甲公司的财产跟王明的财产混乱,之后乙公司再次起诉,要求支付货款,并要求王明和李丽对甲公司债务承担连带责任。诉讼过程中,甲公司向法院提出以下抗辩:(1)甲公司认为西河区人民法院没有管辖权，此案应该由自己所在地东山区人民法院管辖,因为设备已经完成安装,无法拆除,应属于不动产,协议管辖无效,西河区人民法院没有管辖权。(2)甲公司认为买卖合同约定的管辖是西河区人民法院,但是培训协议并没有约定管辖,合同履行地与被告住所地都是东山区人民法院，因此西河区人民法院对《培训合同》没有管辖权。(3)买卖合同和培训协议没有实质关联,法院不能合并审理。(4)乙公司的起诉状副本已经送达甲公司,故在第一次起诉时,甲公司与乙公司的《设备买卖合同》已经解除,乙公司第二次起诉要求履行合同是不成立的,且乙公司并非适格原告。王明同意甲公司的抗辩,承认自己对《设备买卖合同》承担连带保证责任,但主张自已不应承担《培训合同》的连带责任。李丽同意甲公司的抗辩,并且认为自己在两份合同中都没有签字,不应当承担连带责任,自己不是适格被告。诉讼过程中乙公司提出了保全申请,申请查封锦绣小区A房屋。法院经审查发现,2021年王明曾与丁房地产开发商签订A房屋买卖合同,该合同价款为600万元,王明支付了400万元首付款,剩余房款自丙银行办理了按揭贷款,并于2021年12月为丙银行办理了A房屋抵押权预告登记。2022年1月,房屋建成,丁公司办理了所有权首次登记。乙公司申请保全时,房屋尚未过户给王明,且查明王明故意拖延不办过户。于是法院作出准予査封A房屋裁定,但由于王明没有取得房屋所有权,故无法进行查封,法院只进行了公告。法院还查明,王明曾经转移甲公司的财产用于A房屋的装修等。后A房屋被乙公司申请执行,丙银行提出异议,认为该房屋有自已的抵押预告登记,不能被执行。另外,王明的律师也提出抗辩:认为该房屋展于王明的唯一住房(系属实)。","parent_id":3988,"category_id":"3989","category_name":"2023年民商诉综合","level":"normal","status":"empty","is_answer":false,"user_answer":"","answer":"","right_num":0,"total_num":0,"wrong_num":0,"user_right_num":0,"user_total_num":0,"user_wrong_num":0,"user_rate":0,"rate":0,"start_time":0,"end_time":0,"time":0,"collect":false,"asks":[{"id":23,"index":1,"score":2,"content":"原告申请撒诉,法院没有经过被告同意,同意撒诉了(甲无力偿还,并且乙认为诉讼没有意义),法院同意撤诉是否正确?(6分)","status":"empty","is_answer":false,"user_answer":"","user_score":0,"answer":"","ask_record_id":0,"review":""},{"id":24,"index":1,"score":2,"content":"乙公司起诉甲公司、王明、李丽、针对甲公司提出的抗辩,即对管辖异议、诉讼请求、诉讼参与人、两个诉讼请求能否合并等进行分析。(7分)","status":"empty","is_answer":false,"user_answer":"","user_score":0,"answer":"","ask_record_id":0,"review":""},{"id":25,"index":1,"score":2,"content":"人民法院对锦绣小区A房屋的查封有没有生效?(6分)","status":"empty","is_answer":false,"user_answer":"","user_score":0,"answer":"","ask_record_id":0,"review":""},{"id":26,"index":1,"score":2,"content":"关于买卖合同,对王明和李丽是否承担连带保证责任进行分析。(6分)","status":"empty","is_answer":false,"user_answer":"","user_score":0,"answer":"","ask_record_id":0,"review":""},{"id":27,"index":1,"score":2,"content":"关于培训协议,对王明和李丽是否承担连带责任进行分析。(6分)","status":"empty","is_answer":false,"user_answer":"","user_score":0,"answer":"","ask_record_id":0,"review":""},{"id":28,"index":1,"score":2,"content":"对于丙银行执行异议法院是否支持。(6分)","status":"empty","is_answer":false,"user_answer":"","user_score":0,"answer":"","ask_record_id":0,"review":""},{"id":29,"index":1,"score":2,"content":"能否请求支付买卖合同项下的款项80万元和赔偿迟延损失?(6分)","status":"empty","is_answer":false,"user_answer":"","user_score":0,"answer":"","ask_record_id":0,"review":""},{"id":30,"index":1,"score":2,"content":"能否请求支付培训合同项下的款项20万元和赔偿迟延损失?(6分)","status":"empty","is_answer":false,"user_answer":"","user_score":0,"answer":"","ask_record_id":0,"review":""},{"id":31,"index":1,"score":2,"content":"债务人王明用房子给银行设置了抵押预告登记,请分析债务人只有一所住房且银行未正式办理抵押登记对于优先受偿权的影响。(7分)","status":"empty","is_answer":false,"user_answer":"","user_score":0,"answer":"","ask_record_id":0,"review":""}]}],"created_at":"2025-06-09 09:27:58","finished_at":""},"error":{}}